Bring a Trailer prices · 2010 to 2015

What will my Ferrari 458 sell for on Bring a Trailer?

Italia, Spider and Speciale each have their own market, and the Speciale's sits far above the other two.

Below is every Ferrari 458 auction we have on record from Bring a Trailer's published results, kept apart by variant. We are an official Bring a Trailer Local Partner, so this is the same record we use when a seller asks us what to expect.

82Sold since Nov 2024
80%Of auctions ended in a sale
$161,000Most recent, Nov 12, 2026
Nov 13, 2026Results read
What would mine sell for?Sell on BaT with usCall (610) 235-2416

What each one sells for

VariantMedianRangeSoldSold rateMost recent
458 Italia$234,117 $140,600 to $501,0003578% $260,000, Nov 11, 2026
458 Spider$279,000 $156,000 to $500,0003782% $161,000, Nov 12, 2026
458 Speciale$752,000 $448,600 to $1,129,000788% $1,016,500, Oct 1, 2026
458 Speciale A–too few to average $2,125,000150% $2,125,000, Jul 22, 2026
Modified, race and other–mixed group, see the list $153,000 to $348,000267% $348,000, Nov 9, 2026

Figures are for auctions that ended since Nov 2024. Prices are winning bids; the buyer pays Bring a Trailer's fee on top. "Sold rate" is the share of auctions that met reserve. A variant with fewer than 3 sales shows no median: one or two cars are not a market.

Every sale

129 sales
$100K$200K$500K$1M$2M$5M202520262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: bid to $380,000, not sold, Nov 4, 20262014 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: bid to $400,000, not sold, Oct 28, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: bid to $248,001, not sold, Oct 19, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: bid to $285,458, not sold, Oct 8, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: bid to $415,000, not sold, Oct 7, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: bid to $285,000, not sold, Oct 6, 20262010 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: bid to $252,000, not sold, Oct 2, 20262015 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: bid to $395,000, not sold, Oct 1, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: bid to $245,000, not sold, Sep 28, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: bid to $405,000, not sold, Sep 28, 20262014 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: bid to $358,005, not sold, Sep 17, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: bid to $350,000, not sold, Aug 21, 20262011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: bid to $366,500, not sold, Aug 14, 20262015 Ferrari 458, 458 Speciale A: bid to $1,525,000, not sold, Nov 20, 20252014 Ferrari 458, 458 Speciale: bid to $700,000, not sold, Nov 19, 20252010 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: bid to $142,000, not sold, Nov 13, 20252011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: bid to $157,000, not sold, Sep 2, 20252011 Ferrari 458, Modified, race and other · modified engine: bid to $167,000, not sold, Aug 5, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: bid to $188,000, not sold, Jun 17, 20252010 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: bid to $168,801, not sold, Apr 25, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: bid to $192,911, not sold, Mar 7, 20252014 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $161,000, Nov 12, 20262011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $260,000, Nov 11, 20262011 Ferrari 458, Modified, race and other · modified: $348,000, Nov 9, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $405,458, Nov 7, 20262014 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $340,000, Nov 5, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $300,000, Nov 2, 20262014 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $335,000, Oct 27, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $257,458, Oct 25, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $290,000, Oct 21, 20262010 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $250,000, Oct 15, 20262014 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $410,000, Oct 14, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $440,000, Oct 12, 20262014 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $355,000, Oct 9, 20262015 Ferrari 458, 458 Speciale: $1,016,500, Oct 1, 20262012 Ferrari 458, Modified, race and other: $153,000, Sep 26, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $341,000, Sep 24, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $459,999, Sep 23, 20262011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $234,117, Sep 21, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $500,000, Sep 5, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $425,000, Aug 29, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $400,058, Aug 28, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $490,000, Aug 25, 20262015 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $501,000, Aug 19, 20262011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $290,000, Aug 12, 20262010 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $235,786, Aug 5, 20262015 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $470,000, Aug 5, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $397,000, Jul 29, 20262015 Ferrari 458, 458 Speciale: $920,000, Jul 29, 20262010 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $285,919, Jul 28, 20262015 Ferrari 458, 458 Speciale A: $2,125,000, Jul 22, 20262014 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $450,000, Jul 21, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $310,000, Jul 14, 20262011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $293,000, Jun 24, 20262014 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $342,000, Jun 22, 20262015 Ferrari 458, 458 Speciale: $1,129,000, Jun 11, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $353,000, May 27, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $225,000, May 13, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $180,000, Apr 29, 20262014 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $202,000, Apr 20, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $234,000, Apr 13, 20262011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $233,000, Apr 6, 20262014 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider · one owner: $368,458, Mar 28, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $255,458, Feb 26, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $224,580, Feb 13, 20262015 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $299,000, Jan 28, 20262012 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $270,000, Jan 21, 20262013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $350,000, Jan 14, 20262010 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $170,000, Dec 26, 20252011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $188,777, Dec 18, 20252014 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $156,000, Dec 16, 20252011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $140,600, Dec 11, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $201,000, Nov 25, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $276,500, Nov 18, 20252010 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $162,650, Oct 19, 20252015 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $265,000, Oct 15, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $174,000, Oct 5, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $257,000, Sep 26, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $287,500, Sep 16, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $249,009, Sep 3, 20252011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $213,000, Aug 26, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $187,420, Aug 21, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $172,405, Aug 14, 20252011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $262,000, Jul 31, 20252015 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $295,000, Jul 29, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $241,500, Jul 18, 20252011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $217,000, Jul 5, 20252015 Ferrari 458, 458 Speciale: $650,000, Jul 3, 20252015 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $303,330, Jun 24, 20252011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $205,000, Jun 4, 20252014 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $267,500, Jun 2, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $238,000, May 3, 20252013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $279,000, Apr 18, 20252015 Ferrari 458, 458 Speciale: $612,000, Apr 18, 20252012 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $213,222, Apr 11, 20252010 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $148,789, Mar 15, 20252015 Ferrari 458, 458 Speciale: $752,000, Mar 6, 20252011 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $166,000, Feb 27, 20252015 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $231,000, Jan 21, 20252015 Ferrari 458, 458 Speciale: $448,600, Dec 13, 20242013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $250,000, Nov 30, 20242013 Ferrari 458, 458 Spider: $222,000, Nov 21, 20242014 Ferrari 458, 458 Italia: $190,000, Nov 18, 2024
SoldSold by Reimel Motor CarsBid to, not soldSince Nov 2024, price on a log scale
EndedCarColorMilesPriceSource
Nov 12, 2026 2014 Ferrari 458458 Spider White over Rosso – $161,000 BaT listing ↗
Nov 11, 2026 2011 Ferrari 458458 Italia Rosso Corsa over Beige 27k mi $260,000 BaT listing ↗
Nov 9, 2026 2011 Ferrari 458Modified, race and other · modified Nero interior – $348,000 BaT listing ↗
Nov 7, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Italia Rosso Scuderia 8k mi $405,458 BaT listing ↗
Nov 5, 2026 2014 Ferrari 458458 Spider Rosso Scuderia over Nero – $340,000 BaT listing ↗
Nov 2, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Spider Bianco Avus over Rosso 24k mi $300,000 BaT listing ↗
Oct 27, 2026 2014 Ferrari 458458 Italia – 13k mi $335,000 BaT listing ↗
Oct 25, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Spider Argento Nurburgring over Nero – $257,458 BaT listing ↗
Oct 21, 2026 2012 Ferrari 458458 Spider Crema interior 10k mi $290,000 BaT listing ↗
Oct 15, 2026 2010 Ferrari 458458 Italia Rosso Corsa over Beige 33k mi $250,000 BaT listing ↗
Oct 14, 2026 2014 Ferrari 458458 Spider Rosso Corsa over Nero 10k mi $410,000 BaT listing ↗
Oct 12, 2026 2012 Ferrari 458458 Italia Giallo Modena over Nero 2,400 mi $440,000 BaT listing ↗
Oct 9, 2026 2014 Ferrari 458Sold by Reimel458 Italia Argento Nurburgring over Nero 12k mi $355,000 BaT listing ↗
Oct 1, 2026 2015 Ferrari 458458 Speciale Rosso Scuderia over Nero – $1,016,500 BaT listing ↗
Sep 26, 2026 2012 Ferrari 458Modified, race and other Yellow – $153,000 BaT listing ↗
Sep 24, 2026 2012 Ferrari 458458 Italia Bianco Avus over Nero 9k mi $341,000 BaT listing ↗
Sep 23, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Spider Rosso Scuderia over Nero 7k mi $459,999 BaT listing ↗
Sep 21, 2026 2011 Ferrari 458458 Italia Rosso Scuderia over Charcoal – $234,117 BaT listing ↗
Sep 5, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Spider Red interior 7k mi $500,000 BaT listing ↗
Aug 29, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Spider Nero over Beige Tradizione 7k mi $425,000 BaT listing ↗
Aug 28, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Spider Rosso Corsa over Nero – $400,058 BaT listing ↗
Aug 25, 2026 2012 Ferrari 458458 Spider Argento Nurburgring over Black 4,400 mi $490,000 BaT listing ↗
Aug 19, 2026 2015 Ferrari 458458 Italia Bianco Avus over Nero 1,800 mi $501,000 BaT listing ↗
Aug 12, 2026 2011 Ferrari 458458 Italia Grigio Silverstone over Nero – $290,000 BaT listing ↗
Aug 5, 2026 2010 Ferrari 458458 Italia Rosso Corsa over Black 28k mi $235,786 BaT listing ↗
Aug 5, 2026 2015 Ferrari 458458 Italia Bianco Avus over Nero 1,200 mi $470,000 BaT listing ↗
Jul 29, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Spider Rosso Corsa over Beige 11k mi $397,000 BaT listing ↗
Jul 29, 2026 2015 Ferrari 458458 Speciale Rosso Scuderia over Nero – $920,000 BaT listing ↗
Jul 28, 2026 2010 Ferrari 458458 Italia Black over Black 28k mi $285,919 BaT listing ↗
Jul 22, 2026 2015 Ferrari 458458 Speciale A Bianco Avus over Blu Sterling 2,200 mi $2,125,000 BaT listing ↗

What would yours sell for?

Pick the variant and type the mileage. We'll show the Bring a Trailer sales closest to your car and the range they sold in.

A guide from past results, not an appraisal. For a number on your car, send us the details: the valuation is free.

Bid to, not sold

These cars did not meet reserve. The high bid is not a sale price and is not counted in any price figure above. The newest 25 are shown.

EndedCarColorMilesPriceSource
Nov 4, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Spider Bianco Avus over Rosso 6k mi $380,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Oct 28, 2026 2014 Ferrari 458458 Spider Black interior 8k mi $400,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Oct 19, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Spider – – $248,001bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Oct 8, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Italia Bianco Avus 8,500 mi $285,458bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Oct 7, 2026 2012 Ferrari 458458 Spider Nero over Black 8k mi $415,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Oct 6, 2026 2012 Ferrari 458458 Spider – 35k mi $285,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Oct 2, 2026 2010 Ferrari 458458 Italia Rosso Corsa over Black 29k mi $252,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Oct 1, 2026 2015 Ferrari 458458 Italia Rosso Corsa over Tan 4,400 mi $395,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Sep 28, 2026 2012 Ferrari 458458 Spider Grigio Silverstone over Nero – $245,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Sep 28, 2026 2013 Ferrari 458458 Spider Grigio Silverstone over Black 2,500 mi $405,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Sep 17, 2026 2014 Ferrari 458458 Italia Rosso Corsa over Black 8k mi $358,005bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Aug 21, 2026 2012 Ferrari 458458 Italia – 9k mi $350,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Aug 14, 2026 2011 Ferrari 458458 Italia – 9k mi $366,500bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Nov 20, 2025 2015 Ferrari 458458 Speciale A Rosso Corsa 992 mi $1,525,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Nov 19, 2025 2014 Ferrari 458458 Speciale Nero Daytona over Nero 7k mi $700,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Nov 13, 2025 2010 Ferrari 458458 Italia Gray over Black – $142,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Sep 2, 2025 2011 Ferrari 458458 Italia Nero interior 25k mi $157,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Aug 5, 2025 2011 Ferrari 458Modified, race and other · modified engine Rosso Corsa – $167,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Jun 17, 2025 2013 Ferrari 458458 Italia Rosso Corsa over Beige 15k mi $188,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Apr 25, 2025 2010 Ferrari 458458 Italia Bianco Avus over Nero – $168,801bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Mar 7, 2025 2013 Ferrari 458458 Spider Nero DS over Beige Tradizione – $192,911bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Sep 4, 2024 2010 Ferrari 458458 Italia Giallo Modena over Nero 14k mi $166,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Aug 12, 2024 2014 Ferrari 458458 Italia Bianco Avus over Red 9k mi $205,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Jul 23, 2024 2015 Ferrari 458458 Spider Grigio Silverstone over Beige 18k mi $207,000bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗
Jul 16, 2024 2012 Ferrari 458458 Spider Cuoio interior 18k mi $196,458bid to, not sold BaT listing ↗

Ferrari 458 cars we've sold

All Ferrari →
Sold
ZFF78VHL1F02118661,512 Miles
2015 Ferrari
458
SOLD
Sold
ZFF75VFA3F02051086,000 Miles
2015 Ferrari
458
SOLD
Sold
ZFF67NFA5E019774411,770 Miles
2014 Ferrari
458 Italia
SOLD
Sold
ZFF75VFA3F02051085,827 Miles
2015 Ferrari
458
SOLD
Sold
ZFF68NHA7D019356016,159 Miles
2013 Ferrari
458 Spider
SOLD
Sold
ZFF68NHA2D019147325,954 Miles
2013 Ferrari
458 Spider
SOLD
Sold
ZFF68NHA8D019236710,850 Miles
2013 Ferrari
458
SOLD

How to read these numbers

  • Every price is a completed Bring a Trailer sale and links to its listing. Asking prices are not counted anywhere.
  • The price is the winning bid. The buyer pays Bring a Trailer's fee on top of it.
  • Variants are never averaged together, and conversions, race cars and projects are listed but left out of the medians.
  • Mileage and colors are read from each listing's title and short description. Mileage is rounded there, so a "22k" car may have a few hundred miles either side, and a dash means the listing's summary didn't state it.
  • Cars we sold ourselves are marked and open the car's own page, with its photos and history.

Reimel Motor Cars is an independent dealer and an official Bring a Trailer Local Partner. This page is our own summary of published results and is not produced or endorsed by Bring a Trailer.

Selling your Ferrari 458?

We'll run the Bring a Trailer auction for you

We've run 95 Bring a Trailer auctions and 80% of them sold. We handle the detail, photos, video, listing and the questions from bidders, and we arrange enclosed transport nationwide. If an auction isn't the right route, we also buy outright and consign.

Free valuationSell your Ferrari